Recently I was reading a little article written by Pope
Benedict in 2002 on the topic of beauty. He writes about
what seems to be a paradox. The Church talks about the
beauty of Christ, using this verse from Ps. 44: "You are
the fairest of the children of men and grace is poured
upon your lips." Benedict says that this psalm verse,
applied to Christ, is not speaking merely of human
external beauty, but the beauty of the truth that is in
Christ, the beauty of God Himself, Who draws us to
Himself.
But the Church also, talking about Christ's suffering
and passion speaks of Him using the words from Isaiah
53, Verse 2: "He had neither beauty, nor majesty,
nothing to attract our eyes, no grace to make us delight
in Him." So here, in His passion the Church says not
only is Christ not physically beautiful, He looks so
wretched that nobody wants to even look at Him. This
seeming contradiction interested the Fathers. Is beauty
true, or does ugliness show us what is true? The beauty
of truth that is in Christ is the same truth that
embraces suffering, pain and even the dark mystery of
death.
Benedict describes the two ways one can see the beauty
of the truth. The first way is by being taught about the
truth. But the second way is through personal
experience, through direct contact with the source of
all truth. As Nicholas Casabilis wrote, "When men have a
longing so great that it surpasses human nature and they
eagerly desire and can accomplish things beyond human
thought, it is Christ the Bridegroom Who has smitten
them with this longing. It is He Who has sent a ray of
His beauty into their eyes. The greatness of the wound
already shows the arrow which has struck home."
Benedict says that icons are a good example of this. Our
eyes see the painting and we may judge it to be
beautiful or not on the basis of simply what our eyes
see, the way the icon affects our sense of beauty. But,
if we look beyond just color, shape, technique and see
icons with our inner eye of faith, we can see beyond
what any art critic might also see, and we move towards
seeing a beauty that is much richer and deeper, the
beauty of the glory of God.
People have always wondered, Benedict says, whether
there is such a thing as the beauty of truth when we can
also see around us lies, seduction, violence and evil.
Can the beautiful be genuine, or is it just simply an
illusion? Maybe it's not the arrow of the beautiful that
leads us to truth, but instead maybe it is lies and all
that is ugly and vulgar—maybe that's the truth and
we just have to face up to it. After all, look at all
the wars and utter brutality of the 20th century's
history.
So, is Christ the "fairest of the children of men," or
the one Who "had no beauty, no majesty to draw our eyes,
no grace to make us delight in Him?" He is both. In His
suffering and passion that which might seem to be only
dark and ugly is not removed but it is overcome. The
experience of the beautiful becomes even deeper and more
real.
"The One Who is Beauty itself allows Himself to be
slapped in the face, spat upon crowned with thorns; the
Shroud of Turin helps us imagine this in a realistic
way. However in His face that is so disfigured there
appears the genuine and extreme beauty: the beauty of
love that goes 'to the very end;' for this reason, it is
shown to be greater than lies and violence. Whoever can
perceive this beauty knows that truth and not lies is
the real thing that genuine people desire."
And I think a good example of this is on Good Friday
when we come forward to kiss the holy shroud. We are
able to see beyond the suffering and death lying in
front of our eyes on the shroud, something that normally
would make us turn away. Instead we are drawn to it,
because we see the beauty of His love for us even in the
disguise of suffering and pain.
The world of lies and deceptions offers people a beauty
that is, well, a lie and a deception. It's a beauty that
doesn't call us to experience something fine,
magnificent and wonderfully much greater than ourselves.
Instead it locks people entirely into themselves. It
does not stir a desire for God, for sacrificial love,
for selfless living. Instead it stirs up harmful
desires, the will for power, possession and pleasure.
Benedict says that in the Garden of Eden Eve saw the
forbidden fruit as something "beautiful" and "delightful
to the eyes." This attraction of this aroused within her
a desire to possess it and turn away from God, locking
herself into just her desires. The consequences were
tragic. Benedict asks, isn't that what so much of
advertising is about? Create images that tempt us to
want to grab everything and seek temporary satisfaction
instead of being open to others.
Father Ihor a few days ago was showing us some of the
music videos that are popular with young people today.
Now I realize that he was showing us some of the worst
examples, not the best, but I was surprised I'm not as
savvy as I thought. The videos were dark, ugly,
demeaning and full of negative and despairing messages.
And of course they were all about me, me, me. And they
all used strong sexual images, so much so that you would
think the greatest achievement of life is satisfying
your lust. Fr. Ihor said, "And this is what our young
people are watching and listening to." I was sincerely
horrified. "This is what they like."
Now contrast that type of false beauty with the beauty
we saw on the stage outside yesterday. Ask yourselves,
please, where true beauty can be found and how do we
react to it? Does it point us outside of ourselves to
reach out to others in service, to turn our heads in the
direction of God and all that is good? Or does it tempt
us to be selfish and self-centered, using other people
for our own pleasure, and locking ourselves into a world
where God doesn't matter and this physical life is all
that counts.
Benedict concludes: Many people have heard the sentence
Dostoyevsky wrote, "The Beautiful will save us." But not
so many people realize that the Beautiful he was talking
about is Christ.
Dear friends, true beauty is in the beauty of the truth.
That truth is Christ. Let us continue to become more
beautiful ourselves as we continue to desire, to live,
to become more like Christ our Savior.